Skip to Content
Department of Premier and Cabinet


Contact Details

By phone
Find the number of a specific division or office to contact them directly or call Service Tasmania on 1300 135 513.

Our staff
Use the Tasmanian Government Directory to find staff contact details

Social media
Follow our social media accounts to keep up to date with specific programs and initiatives.

Independent Review of the Response to the North-West Tasmania COVID-19 Outbreak

The Premier established an Independent Review to consider the actions, and effectiveness of those actions, taken in response to the COVID-19 outbreak in North-West Tasmania by government agencies, public and private health care facilities, and other relevant authorities.

Greg Melick AO SC was appointed as the Independent Reviewer. An eminent member of Australia’s legal community, he practises as a barrister and mediator in several jurisdictions in both criminal and civil matters. He is also Chief Commissioner and Chair of the Board of Tasmania’s Integrity Commission.

An expert working group was established to advise the Independent Reviewer with members experienced in public health, hospital administration, and public sector administration.

Report and Tasmanian Government Response

The Independent Reviewer submitted the Report to the Premier on 30 November 2020.  Below are links to the Report and Tasmanian Government Response:


The Review considered the actions, and effectiveness of those actions, taken in response to the COVID-19 outbreak in North-West Tasmania by government agencies, public and private health care facilities and any other relevant authorities.

The Independent Reviewer:

  1. Provided an opportunity to persons with a proper interest in the subject matter of this review to make submissions about that subject matter and, if thought necessary, to be heard personally in relation those matters;
  2. Ensured that where necessary appropriate confidentiality arrangements were made for persons assisting the inquiry; and
  3. Ensured the lived experience of North West Coast patients diagnosed with COVID-19 and those placed in quarantine were taken account of.

The Review covered any other matter relevant to the outbreak of COVID-19 in the North West that the Independent Reviewer identifies in the course of Review activities as warranting investigation and discussion.

Terms of Reference

Following consultation the final Terms of Reference were released on 24 July 2020.


24 submissions were received in which the submitter requested that their submission be treated confidentially, either in whole or in part. Some have been published with names or verbatim quotes withheld, and some withheld entirely.  Matters raised in the confidential submissions are largely consistent with the published submissions, and can broadly be summarised as:

  • Communication
  • The physical environment
  • Personal Protective Equipment
  • Coordination
  • Management
  • Staff health and wellbeing.

In addition, submitters regularly pointed out the dedication and hard work of people on the ground responding to the crisis.

Name of submitter (Organisation or Individual)

Health and Community Services Union (Tim Jacobson)

Prof Jus St John

Tasmanian Labor (Sarah Lovell MLC)

Health Consumers Tasmania (Bruce Levett)

Rural Doctors Association of Australia (Dr Benjamin Dodds)

Dr Darren Briggs

Name withheld

Name withheld

Ann O’Rourke

Name withheld

Australian Medical Association (content withheld at request of AMA) Dr Helen McArdle

Australian Nursing and Midwifery Federation (Tasmania) (Emily Shepherd)

Name withheld

Name withheld

Australasian College of Emergency Medicine (Dr John Bonning)

Tasmanian Government

Department of Health

Pharmacy Guild of Tasmania (John Dowling)

Name withheld (6)

National Critical Care and Trauma Response Centre (AUSMAT)